Off-highway vehicle use. Photo Credit: BLM
Emery County Public Land Management Act – Privatization of public lands
Emery County Public Land Management Act
Compromise? More like a devil’s bargain. The Emery County [Utah] Public Land Management Act’s original sponsors, then-Senator Orrin Hatch and Representative John Curtis (both R-UT), touted it as a compromise between conservationists and extractive industries. In reality, the bill would sacrifice the incredible natural features of Emery County—including the famous San Rafael Swell and the Book Cliffs, renowned for backcountry hunting—for off-highway vehicle trails, coal mining, and oil and gas development.
Emery County Public Land Management Act Location
Emery County Public Land Management Act
This bill would bring coal mining, oil and gas development, and expanded motorized use to land renowned for its incredible features and backcountry hunting.
Photo Credit: U.S. Forest Service
Emery County Public Land Management Act – The Details
Conservationists have long sought to protect the incredible natural features of Emery County, Utah, including the Green River’s Labyrinth and Desolation Canyons and the San Rafael Swell, an enormous fold of sedimentary rock measuring 75 miles by 40 miles that rises 1,500 feet above the surrounding landscape. Local and state officials, as well as opponents of federal management of public lands, have opposed protections at every step.
So when the Emery County [Utah] Public Land Management Act was introduced in May 2018, its sponsors, then-Senator Orrin Hatch and Representative John Curtis (both R-UT), pronounced it “a model for how Utahns can work together to solve public land management questions in some of the most unique/controversial areas of the country.” Public lands advocates can only hope it is no such thing, for the Act is a boon to the fossil fuels and motorized recreation industries—it gives public lands to the state for expanding Off-Highway Vehicle (OHV) trails, shrinks a wilderness study area (WSA) to facilitate coal mining, and sets up a land exchange program that will lead to even more coal mining and oil and gas development on what are now federal public lands.
The Act languished on its own in 2018, but Hatch and Curtis convinced Congressional leaders to include it as part of an omnibus public lands bill that nearly passed at the end of the year. The omnibus bill was reintroduced at the start of 2019, which Congress quickly passed as the John D. Dingell, Jr. Conservation, Management, and Recreation Act. President Trump signed the Act into law on March 12, 2019.
The Dingell Act will give away about 10,000 acres of public land in the San Rafael Reef on the eastern edge of the Swell to Utah. The state intends to monetize the Reef’s popularity with motorized recreationists by expanding a state park, developing off-road vehicle trails and other amenities, and charging an entrance fee to what is now public land. The Act gives an additional 2,700 acres of public lands to Emery County’s local governments, a considerable amount of land given the county’s 10,000 residents.
The Act also fulfills a longstanding goal of Utah’s State Institutional Trust Lands Administration (SITLA). The agency, legally obligated to wring maximum revenue from the state’s trust lands, has long wanted to trade the remote, expensive-to-develop parcels it manages in the San Rafael Swell for accessible federal lands with fossil fuels potential elsewhere in the state. The Emery County Act offers up a land exchange program that greases the skids for SITLA by setting tight deadlines for review, prohibiting consideration of alternatives under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), granting exceptions to standard federal appraisal practices for federal lands, and allowing SITLA to select public lands that the Bureau of Land Management hasn’t marked for disposal.
The bill offers one other gift to the fossil fuels industry: it eliminates longstanding protections on nearly 15,000 acres of the Turtle Canyon Wilderness Study Area. This is expected to facilitate coal mining in the Book Cliffs, a premier destination for Utah’s backcountry elk and mule deer hunters.
Hatch and Curtis cloaked their bill as an authentic compromise to resolve longstanding disagreements between conservationists on one side and the resource extraction industries and Emery County commissioners who do their bidding on the other. It is nothing of the sort, but this is no surprise, coming from two politicians who appeared onstage with President Trump when he signed illegal orders shrinking Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante monuments in December 2017.
Don’t Miss Out on Public Lands News!
You’re informed about the most dastardly privatization schemes—now, ensure you stay that way! Join Guardians’ email list and we’ll keep you apprised of what’s going on in the world of public lands.
Public Lands Privatization Schemes
Learn more about the public lands at risk across the United States.
How You Can Help
Help protect the magnificent wild places of the West! Be a guardian for public lands by joining the conversation, learning about current issues, and making your voice heard. Together, we're a powerful force for nature.
Recent Stories From Public Lands
Federal District Court Denies Motion to Dismiss Lawsuits Seeking to Restore Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante
Order states that a “decision regarding the Antiquities Act will necessarily be one on the merits.”
This piece originally appeared in the Santa Fe New Mexican on June 15, 2019
Keeping livestock off public lands has many benefits, but existing law doesn’t allow for permanent livestock grazing permit retirement
Public Lands Press
For centuries, Chaco Canyon was a gathering place where ancestral Puebloan peoples came together to make their world a better place. At the heart of the ancient civilization’s genius are the complex and intricate relationships between its grand architecture, global commerce, ceremonies and their link to solar and lunar cycles.Read more >
Attorneys for the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and Forest Service and others filed a motion with the federal district court in Tucson on Wednesday, requesting the reversal of a judge’s ruling in a Mexican spotted owl case that resulted in a timber ban across six national forests.Read more >