Photo Credit: EcoFlight. Photo of a similar Simplot mine a few miles from the Dairy Syncline proposed site.
Dairy Syncline Mine – Privatization of public lands
Dairy Syncline Mine
Idaho will soon be swimming in two-headed trout if the J.R. Simplot Company gets its way. The company has proposed privatizing public lands as part of its plan to develop an open pit phosphate mine (the Dairy Syncline Mine) in southeastern Idaho. Selenium—a mineral brought to the surface by phosphate mining—has already mutated trout fry downstream of an existing Simplot mine. The Dairy Syncline Mine threatens even greater environmental destruction.
Dairy Syncline Mine Location
Dairy Syncline Mine
A proposed mine threatens selenium contamination and deadly consequences for wildlife.
Photo Credit: U.S. Forest Service
Dairy Syncline Mine – The Details
The J.R. Simplot Company is looking to privatize public lands as part of its plan for another open pit phosphate mine in southeastern Idaho. While Simplot owns two leases underneath the Caribou National Forest that give it rights to mine for phosphate, the multi-national corporation wants federal land for the mine’s tailings pond. Simplot has proposed exchanging 640 acres of its own land nearby for 631 acres of Caribou National Forest land, and purchasing 1,142 acres of land managed by the Bureau of Land Management. Federal law prohibits tailings ponds on National Forest lands, and BLM policy also discourages such facilities on the public lands it manages, so Simplot is banking on privatization to get its mine up and running.
Phosphate is a primary material used in the production of fertilizer. Monsanto also uses phosphate in manufacturing its Roundup™ herbicide. Southeastern Idaho, already home to two phosphate mining-related Superfund sites, is a primary phosphate source in the U.S. Earlier phosphate mining has unearthed toxic levels of selenium that killed horses, cattle and hundreds of sheep. It is especially deadly to aquatic egg-bearing animals, including native Yellowstone cutthroat trout, the prized game fish and iconic species of the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem. Two segments of the local Blackfoot River and 15 of its tributaries are contaminated by selenium well in excess of Idaho’s legal limit.
The Forest Service and BLM are currently evaluating Simplot’s proposal. Although Simplot’s two leases convey a right to mine, the Forest Service and BLM are obligated to deny the land exchange and sale if the transactions are not in the public interest. WildEarth Guardians is working closely with allies to review the proposal and ensure that public interests, water quality, and fish and wildlife habitat are protected.
Don’t Miss Out on Public Lands News!
You’re informed about the most dastardly privatization schemes—now, ensure you stay that way! Join Guardians’ email list and we’ll keep you apprised of what’s going on in the world of public lands.
Public Lands Privatization Schemes
Learn more about the public lands at risk across the United States.
How You Can Help
Help protect the magnificent wild places of the West! Be a guardian for public lands by joining the conversation, learning about current issues, and making your voice heard. Together, we're a powerful force for nature.
Recent Stories From Public Lands
Federal District Court Denies Motion to Dismiss Lawsuits Seeking to Restore Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante
Order states that a “decision regarding the Antiquities Act will necessarily be one on the merits.”
This piece originally appeared in the Santa Fe New Mexican on June 15, 2019
Keeping livestock off public lands has many benefits, but existing law doesn’t allow for permanent livestock grazing permit retirement
Public Lands Press
For centuries, Chaco Canyon was a gathering place where ancestral Puebloan peoples came together to make their world a better place. At the heart of the ancient civilization’s genius are the complex and intricate relationships between its grand architecture, global commerce, ceremonies and their link to solar and lunar cycles.Read more >
Attorneys for the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and Forest Service and others filed a motion with the federal district court in Tucson on Wednesday, requesting the reversal of a judge’s ruling in a Mexican spotted owl case that resulted in a timber ban across six national forests.Read more >